As an Amazon Associate, and through the eBay Partner Network, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page.
The best game like Mafia for most game nights is One Night Ultimate Werewolf: it is Mafia with the moderator and the player elimination removed, and it finishes in about ten minutes. If you have a big group and one person who enjoys running the room, Blood on the Clocktower is Mafia perfected, and it is the one game on this page you should buy from its publisher rather than from Amazon. If you want the lying without the night phase, The Resistance: Avalon is the game to own. And if you only ever have three or four people, Coup gives you Mafia’s bluffing at a size Mafia itself cannot play.
Mafia is four things stacked together: an informed minority hiding inside an uninformed majority, a day of accusations and a night of murders, a moderator who knows everything, and a crowd. Every game below keeps the first part, because that is the part people are asking for. They differ in which of Mafia’s problems they fix: the moderator who cannot play, the person eliminated in round one who sits out the next forty minutes, the dead air while the town argues, and the dozen people you rarely have. So the list is ranked by one question: how much of Mafia does each game keep, and which of its problems does it solve? Every purchase link on this page was checked against its live Amazon listing on 18 November 2026; where a game cannot be bought new at a sane price we say so instead of leaving a button that points at a dead end. Specs are quoted from each publisher where we could reach one.
The 10 best games like Mafia, ranked by what they keep and what they fix
1. Blood on the Clocktower — Mafia perfected, and not sold on Amazon at list price
Publisher: The Pandemonium Institute · 5 to 20 players plus a Storyteller (the publisher’s site, read 18 November 2026; it does not print an age or a running time, so neither do we)
Blood on the Clocktower is what Mafia becomes when a designer spends a decade fixing it. It keeps everything: the hidden Demon and its Minions inside a town of Good players, the day of open argument and private whispers, the night of secret actions, and a Storyteller who runs the game. Then it repairs the two things that make Mafia hurt. Dead players stay in the game, keeping their seat, their voice and one final vote, so nobody who is killed in the first night spends an hour watching. And the Storyteller is given a job worth doing: they hold a Grimoire that tracks every role and they are allowed, within the rules, to choose which true-but-misleading information a drunk or poisoned player receives. The result is a game that is worth running, which is the single biggest reason Mafia nights die out.
It is also expensive, heavy, and built for a crowd. If you do not regularly seat eight or more people, buy it later. If you do, this is the best game of its kind in print, and the only one on this page we would call an event rather than a filler. We cover it at length on our social deduction games page.
Where to buy it: on 18 November 2026 the only Amazon listing for the game had no buy box, and the listing this page used to carry pointed at Amazon Australia, where a US reader cannot buy it. The Pandemonium Institute sells the game directly. The link below is a plain link to the publisher; we earn nothing from it.
2. One Night Ultimate Werewolf — Mafia in ten minutes, no moderator, nobody eliminated
Publisher: Bezier Games · 3–10 players · about 10 minutes · no moderator and no elimination (Bezier’s product page, read 18 November 2026; Bezier does not print an age on that page)
One Night Ultimate Werewolf compresses the whole of Mafia into a single night and a single morning. Everyone gets a secret role, the roles act in the dark in a fixed order (a free app plays the moderator), and then the table has a few minutes to argue before everyone points at once. One vote, one reveal, done. Because so many roles move or swap cards during the night, half the table is no longer sure what they are, which is where the fun lives: you are often defending an identity you have already lost.
This is the game to buy if what you want is Mafia for an ordinary game night. It fixes the moderator (the app), the elimination (there is none), and the time (ten minutes, so you play it five times and the person who was lynched unfairly gets their revenge in the next round). What it loses is the slow build of suspicion over several days; nobody gets to be Mafia for an hour here. Three players is the box minimum and it works, which no other Mafia-shaped game can say. The Daybreak expansion adds more roles; buy it only after the base box has stopped surprising you.
3. The Resistance — Mafia with the night phase replaced by missions
Publisher: Indie Boards & Cards · 5–10 players · about 30 minutes · ages 13 and up · no player elimination (the publisher’s product page, read 18 November 2026)
The Resistance keeps Mafia’s informed minority (the spies) and uninformed majority (the resistance) and throws away the murders. Instead, a leader proposes a team for each mission, the table votes on the team, and the chosen players secretly play a success or a sabotage card. One sabotage fails the mission. Three failed missions and the spies win; three successes and the resistance does. Nobody dies and nobody sits out, and the information you get is harder than a body in the street: a failed mission tells you a spy was on the team, but not which seat.
It is the cleaner design of the two Mafia descendants Indie Boards & Cards publishes, and the one to teach a group that has never played a hidden-team game. It is also the one most people stop playing once they own Avalon, below. Michael owned The Resistance and has since given his copy away; if you are buying one of the two, buy Avalon.
4. The Resistance: Avalon — the same game with Merlin, and the one to own
Publisher: Indie Boards & Cards · 5–10 players · about 30 minutes · ages 14 and up · a standalone game, compatible with The Resistance (the publisher’s product page, read 18 November 2026)
Avalon is The Resistance with special roles, and the roles change the game. Merlin, on the good side, knows who the evil players are but must never be found out, because if good wins the missions, evil gets one shot at naming Merlin and steals the game back. The Assassin, on the evil side, takes that shot. So Merlin spends the whole game steering the table toward the truth without ever looking like the one who knows it, and everyone else spends the game trying to work out which of their good-looking teammates knows too much. That single mechanic gives Avalon the thing The Resistance lacks: a player on the good team with a secret worth protecting.
If you want one hidden-team game for five to ten people with no moderator and no elimination, this is it. Shorter than Blood on the Clocktower, deeper than One Night Ultimate Werewolf, and it fits in a coat pocket. The expansion roles can be added one at a time once the table knows the base game.
5. Secret Hitler — Avalon’s structure with a government, and a theme that divides tables
Publisher: Goat, Wolf, & Cabbage · 5–10 players (the publisher’s site, read 18 November 2026; it prints neither an age nor a running time, and the game is also published free to print under a Creative Commons licence)
Secret Hitler is a hidden-team game in the Resistance family with one extra lever: a government. Each round a President nominates a Chancellor, the table votes the pair in or out, and the two of them draw three policy cards and pass one into law, in secret. Fascist policies pile up even when liberals hold both chairs, because the deck is stacked against them, so every enacted fascist law starts an argument about whether the government was unlucky or lying. The fascists know each other; the liberals know nothing; and if Hitler is elected Chancellor once three fascist laws are in play, the game ends on the spot.
It produces the loudest, funniest table talk of anything on this page, and it is the one game here Michael has played and will not own: the theme does real work in the design, and some tables find that work distasteful rather than dramatic. If your group laughs at the box, buy it. If anyone at your table would not, buy Avalon, which is the same shape of game without the costume. For more in the same vein, our list of games like Secret Hitler goes ten deep.
6. Deception: Murder in Hong Kong — the murderer is at the table, and the forensic scientist cannot speak
Publisher: Grey Fox Games · 4–12 players · about 20 minutes · list price $39.99 (Grey Fox’s own store page, read 18 November 2026; it does not print an age)
Deception keeps Mafia’s hidden killer and throws out both the night phase and the voting rounds. Everyone is an investigator except the murderer, who secretly picks one means-of-murder card and one clue card from the ones in front of them. The forensic scientist knows which two were picked and can only communicate by placing bullet markers on scene tiles: cause of death, location, weather, a trait of the victim. The investigators have to read those hints, match them to the cards on the table, and make one accusation each. The murderer’s job is to look as puzzled as everyone else.
It is the best twelve-player game on this page by a distance, and Michael owns a copy. His honest verdict is also the honest buying question: the event was great and the concept was great, but he is less sure the game itself is great, and he asks what you play when you have eleven people and how often you actually have eleven people. If the answer is often, buy it. If a big table is a twice-a-year occasion, this is a game that will mostly live on the shelf. One warning for shoppers: the Undercover Allies box that Amazon shows alongside it is an expansion and does not play on its own; the button below is the base game.
7. Coup — Mafia’s bluffing for three or four people, in fifteen minutes
Publisher: Indie Boards & Cards · 2–6 players · about 15 minutes · ages 13 and up (the publisher’s product page, read 18 November 2026)
Coup is what you play when there are not enough of you for Mafia. Each player holds two face-down character cards, and on your turn you claim to be one of them to take its action: the Duke taxes, the Assassin kills, the Captain steals, the Contessa blocks. You may claim a card you do not hold. Anyone may call your bluff; whoever is wrong about it loses a card, and losing both puts you out. The whole game is the hidden-identity lie from Mafia, played one claim at a time, with the town’s vote replaced by one person saying “I don’t believe you.”
It is the only game on this page we would recommend for exactly three people, and it is a genuinely good game at four. The elimination that Mafia gets blamed for is here too, and here it does not matter: a knocked-out player waits five minutes, not forty, which is the rule of thumb for whether elimination is acceptable at all. Coup: Rebellion G54 is a bigger standalone version with a modular role set; the original is the one to start with.
8. Insider — a traitor hidden inside a game of twenty questions
Publisher: Oink Games · 4–8 players · about 15 minutes · ages 9 and up (Oink’s product page, read 18 November 2026)
Insider is two games in one small box. First, the table has five minutes to guess a secret word by asking the Master yes-or-no questions. One player, the Insider, already knows the word and has to steer the questions toward it without being obvious. If the word is found, the second game starts: everyone discusses who was pushing a little too hard, and votes. The deduction is quiet, the clues are real (you are reviewing questions people actually asked), and the game never asks anyone to perform.
It is the game on this page that Michael credits with getting his mother to the table with her grandchildren, and his sister with her children, when they do not normally play games at all. That is the strongest recommendation a hidden-role game can carry: the people who refuse to play Mafia will play this, because for five minutes it is only twenty questions. At four players it is thin and at six to eight it sings.
9. Cheese Thief — the Mafia your eight-year-old can run
Publisher: Jolly Thinkers (its product pages did not answer our requests on 18 November 2026, so we are not quoting a player count, age or running time)
Cheese Thief is a hidden-role game for children with the moderator and the elimination both removed. The players are mice dreaming of cheese, one of them is the thief, and a die sets up a different little scenario each round so that the game changes shape as you play. The thief may win alone or by bribing minions with stolen cheese; the sleepers win by catching the thief. Nobody is sent away from the table, and a round is over before a young player has lost interest.
It is on this page for one reason: it is the only Mafia-shaped game here a primary-school child can play and understand without an adult running it. A buying note: the listing this page used to carry pointed at Amazon UK, and the same product on Amazon US was priced at eighty dollars on 18 November 2026, three times what this game should cost. The button below goes to a different, current US listing at a normal price; check which one you are in before you pay.
10. The Castle of the Devil — secret societies in a carriage, still in stock
Publisher: dV Giochi (its catalogue lists the game but prints no player count, age or running time, so we are not quoting one; read 18 November 2026)
The Castle of the Devil is the oddest and oldest game on this page. The players are passengers in a carriage racing toward the Devil’s castle, each secretly a member of one of two societies, each holding a secret profession. On your turn you trade cards, duel, spy, or declare victory, and the declaration is the whole game: you must name your society and say which players hold the three artifacts it needs. Guess right and your side wins; guess wrong and you lose the game for everyone on your team.
It keeps Mafia’s hidden allegiance and replaces the vote with a deduction puzzle about who is holding what, which makes it closer to a card game than a shouting match. We were surprised to find it still buyable at a normal price on 18 November 2026; it has been out of its publisher’s spotlight for years. It is here for groups that want hidden teams without the Mafia theatrics and have already worn out Avalon.
If what you want is Mafia itself, buy the printed version
Ultimate Werewolf, from the same publisher as One Night, is Mafia as designed: a moderator, days and nights, a village that shrinks by one each round, and a deck of role cards that scales from a handful of players to a hall full of them. If you have the crowd and a volunteer who enjoys running the room, you do not need an alternative to Mafia, you need a good copy of it, and this is the one to own. Bezier describes it as a game for two teams run by a Moderator who is not on either team; it does not print a player range on its product page, so we are not quoting one.
Three games this page used to recommend, checked on 18 November 2026
We do not delete games from a list when they go out of print; we say what happened, because the next reader may already own one. These three were on the old version of this page with purchase buttons. None of the three can be bought new at a sane price today.
Scape Goat — listed by its publisher, no longer sold by Amazon
Scape Goat is a three-to-six-player card game in which a gang of goats tries to pin a bank job on one of their own, except nobody is certain who the scapegoat is and it may be you. Indie Boards & Cards still lists it (3–6 players, about 30 minutes, ages 14 and up), but the Amazon listing this page carried had no buy box on 18 November 2026 and a search for the game returned none. The button below is a search, not a listing, so you can see whatever is actually for sale before you buy.
Shadows Over Camelot — the traitor game with a board, out of stock
Shadows Over Camelot is the cooperative knights-of-the-round-table game that may, or may not, have a traitor at the table, and it is the only game on this page that plays for an hour or more. Days of Wonder’s own Amazon listing describes it as a game for 3–7 players, ages 10 and up, running 60–90 minutes; Days of Wonder’s website refused our request, so that listing is our only publisher source. On 18 November 2026 the listing had no buy box and no other seller surfaced in search. If you want a long cooperative game with a possible traitor, it is still worth finding secondhand; the button below is a search so you can judge the price.
Locke & Key: Shadow of Doubt — out of print, and this page was selling the wrong thing
Locke & Key: Shadow of Doubt was a hidden-traitor game based on the comic, published by IDW Games, which has since closed. It is not sold new. The purchase box the old version of this page carried under this heading was selling Locke & Key: Keys to the Kingdom, Vol. 4, a graphic novel, and had been for some time; we found it on 18 November 2026 and removed it. The only Locke & Key game Amazon sells today is Locke and Key: The Game, a 2012 card game from a different publisher, which is not the game described here. If you want Shadow of Doubt, the secondary market is the only route.
If what you liked about Mafia was…
- The crowd. Our pages on board games for large groups and games for ten players cover the rest of the shelf. Michael’s own answer for eight is a confession: he would almost always rather play Cockroach Poker, but Cockroach Poker does not play to eight, so Cash ’n Guns stays in his collection on player count alone, and he notes its player elimination is survivable only because the game is fast.
- The lying. Bang! is a hidden-role shootout, the Sheriff against the Outlaws, and it is on our games like Munchkin page with Michael’s verdict on why a mechanically ordinary game keeps getting asked for.
- Two teams in two rooms. Two Rooms and a Boom is the hidden-team game for twenty people that Mafia pretends to be: the whole party splits between two rooms and trades hostages, and nobody is ever eliminated.
- The whodunit. If the murder mattered more than the mob, our games like Clue and mystery board games lists are the next stop.
- The whole genre. The best social deduction board games page is the hub for everything above, and deduction board games covers the quieter, puzzle-shaped end of it.
- A party game that is not about lying at all. Our ranked party games and games like Charades pages are where Michael’s own favourites live.
Want the ten games we would build a collection around? Get our free Top 10 Must-Have Games guide, written from the shelf, not the sales charts.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best board game like Mafia?
The best board game like Mafia is One Night Ultimate Werewolf for an ordinary game night: it keeps the hidden werewolves and the accusations, drops the moderator and the player elimination, and finishes in about ten minutes for 3–10 players. For a large group with a willing Storyteller, Blood on the Clocktower is the best Mafia-style game in print.
What game is like Mafia but without a moderator?
The games like Mafia with no moderator are One Night Ultimate Werewolf, which uses a free app for the night phase, and the mission-based games The Resistance, The Resistance: Avalon and Secret Hitler, in which hidden teams vote on missions or governments instead of killing at night. Coup and Insider also run without a moderator.
What is a game like Mafia for a small group?
The best game like Mafia for a small group is Coup, which plays 2–6 and is genuinely good with three or four, because each player bluffs about two hidden character cards. One Night Ultimate Werewolf works from three players, and Insider, a hidden-traitor word game from Oink Games, plays 4–8 in about fifteen minutes.
Which games like Mafia have no player elimination?
The games like Mafia with no player elimination are One Night Ultimate Werewolf, The Resistance, The Resistance: Avalon, Secret Hitler, Deception: Murder in Hong Kong and Insider, all of which keep every player in until the end. Blood on the Clocktower does kill players, but the dead keep their seat, keep talking and keep one final vote.
Is Blood on the Clocktower sold on Amazon?
Blood on the Clocktower was not sold on Amazon at a normal price when we checked on 18 November 2026: the only US listing had no buy box, and older links point to Amazon Australia. The Pandemonium Institute sells the game directly from its own site, for 5 to 20 players plus a Storyteller, and that is where we recommend buying it.